Neighborhoods with the most waterfront, lake and pond homes for sale in Central Ohio
Candlewood Lake, Mount Gilead has the most waterfront, lake and pond homes for sale in Central Ohio right now: 9 listings, as of October 19, 2026.
How this is ranked: Neighborhoods ranked by how many of their listings for sale match: Homes on or overlooking water: riverfront, lakefront, pond lots and lake access. Matched on MLS fields where the feed carries them, otherwise on the listing agent's own description. Updated Oct 19, 2026, 6:08 PM ET.
-
1. Candlewood Lake · Mount Gilead 9 waterfront, lake and pond homes
9 of the 18 listings here are waterfront, lake and pond homes; median asking across the neighborhood $539,945.
- For sale
- 18
- Asking
- $147,000 to $1,385,000
- Typical home
- 3 bd, 2,224 sq ft
- Built around
- 2000
- Schools
- Northmor Local School District
-
2. Hidden Lake · Columbus 5 waterfront, lake and pond homes
5 of the 7 listings here are waterfront, lake and pond homes; median asking across the neighborhood $345,000.
- For sale
- 7
- Asking
- $169,900 to $389,900
- Typical home
- 2 bd, 1,680 sq ft
- Built around
- 1974
- Schools
- Columbus City School District
-
3. Buckstone Bend · Lockbourne 4 waterfront, lake and pond homes
4 of the 7 listings here are waterfront, lake and pond homes; median asking across the neighborhood $424,900.
- For sale
- 7
- Asking
- $409,900 to $469,900
- Typical home
- 4 bd, 2,605 sq ft
- Built around
- 2026
- Schools
- Hamilton Local School District
-
4. Hidden Springs · Lewis Center 4 waterfront, lake and pond homes
4 of the 5 listings here are waterfront, lake and pond homes; median asking across the neighborhood $305,000.
- For sale
- 5
- Asking
- $244,900 to $319,900
- Typical home
- 2 bd, 1,843 sq ft
- Built around
- 2005
- Schools
- Olentangy Local School District
-
5. Fox Glen · Pickerington 4 waterfront, lake and pond homes
4 of the 4 listings here are waterfront, lake and pond homes; median asking across the neighborhood $496,450.
- For sale
- 4
- Asking
- $419,000 to $530,000
- Typical home
- 4 bd, 2,614 sq ft
- Built around
- 2004
- Schools
- Pickerington Local School District
-
6. Choctaw Lake · London 3 waterfront, lake and pond homes
3 of the 9 listings here are waterfront, lake and pond homes; median asking across the neighborhood $439,900.
- For sale
- 9
- Asking
- $319,900 to $1,249,999
- Typical home
- 3 bd, 2,507 sq ft
- Built around
- 1975
- Schools
- London City School District
-
7. Fairfield Beach · Thornville 3 waterfront, lake and pond homes
3 of the 9 listings here are waterfront, lake and pond homes; median asking across the neighborhood $350,000.
- For sale
- 9
- Asking
- $299,000 to $395,000
- Typical home
- 3 bd, 1,344 sq ft
- Built around
- 1964
- Schools
- Walnut Township Local School District
-
8. Heritage Preserve · Hilliard 3 waterfront, lake and pond homes
3 of the 5 listings here are waterfront, lake and pond homes; median asking across the neighborhood $625,000.
- For sale
- 5
- Asking
- $500,000 to $645,000
- Typical home
- 4 bd, 2,940 sq ft
- Built around
- 2018
- Schools
- Hilliard City School District
-
9. Rolling Hills · Sunbury 3 waterfront, lake and pond homes
3 of the 4 listings here are waterfront, lake and pond homes; median asking across the neighborhood $602,450.
- For sale
- 4
- Asking
- $585,000 to $645,000
- Typical home
- 4 bd, 3,086 sq ft
- Built around
- 2022
- Schools
- Big Walnut Local School District
-
10. Farmstead · Grove City 2 waterfront, lake and pond homes
2 of the 20 listings here are waterfront, lake and pond homes; median asking across the neighborhood $567,500.
- For sale
- 20
- Asking
- $399,900 to $859,999
- Typical home
- 4 bd, 2,600 sq ft
- Built around
- 2024
- Schools
- South-Western City School District
About this list
Neighborhoods with the most waterfront, lake and pond homes for sale in Central Ohio: which is number one?
Candlewood Lake, Mount Gilead has the most waterfront, lake and pond homes for sale in Central Ohio right now: 9 listings, as of October 19, 2026.
How is this list ranked?
Neighborhoods ranked by how many of their listings for sale match: Homes on or overlooking water: riverfront, lakefront, pond lots and lake access. Matched on MLS fields where the feed carries them, otherwise on the listing agent's own description.
How current is this list?
It rebuilds from the MLS every six hours. This version is from October 19, 2026. Sold figures, where used, run January 1 through September 28, 2026.
I'm Adam Geuy, a REALTOR with Blacktree Realty. Pick two or three from this list and I'll pull the comparable sales and walk them with you. Call or text 937-239-2919.
More ranked lists: The 10 Most Affordable Neighborhoods in Central Ohio · The 10 Most Expensive Neighborhoods in Central Ohio · The 10 Neighborhoods With the Most Homes for Sale in Central Ohio · The 10 Neighborhoods With the Most New Construction in Central Ohio · The 10 Neighborhoods With the Biggest Lots in Central Ohio · The 10 Newest Neighborhoods in Central Ohio · The 10 Neighborhoods Where Sellers Are Cutting Prices in Central Ohio · The 10 Most Affordable Condo Communities in Central Ohio
Listings from the MLS Internet Data Exchange program, refreshed every six hours. Listing information is provided by the Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS through the Internet Data Exchange program and is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Listings held by brokerages other than Blacktree Realty are identified with the listing brokerage's name. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
Search the inventory another way: all homes for sale, just listed, open houses, price reductions, highest price first, lowest first.
What actually sold, by geography: school districts, ZIP codes, counties, neighborhoods, cities, homes by feature, new construction. Or have Adam run the search.