3 homes for sale in Fenway, New Albany

3 homes are for sale in Fenway as of October 19, 2026. The count comes from the MLS's public listing feed and refreshes every six hours; a listing whose seller opted out of internet display will not appear here.

Asking prices in Fenway run from $1,375,000 to $1,675,000, with a median asking price of $1,499,000.

That depends on what you want from a home, and the honest answer comes from the numbers rather than adjectives. In Fenway right now: the median home for sale asks $1,499,000, the typical home was built around 1995, lots run about 0.34 acres, most listings are in the New Albany Plain Local School District and HOA fees, where listed, run about $124 a month. Walk two or three of the listings on this page with me and you will know in an afternoon whether it fits.

The median listing in Fenway has 6 bedrooms and 5.5 bathrooms and about 5,243 finished square feet, built around 1995. The median asking price works out to about $306 a square foot of finished space.

Every home for sale in Fenway right now is a single-family home.

Every listing in Fenway with a district on record is in the New Albany Plain Local School District. The district comes from each listing's MLS record; attendance zones move, so confirm the assigned schools for any specific address with the district.

A median of 80 days as of October 19, 2026. That is the age of the listings still for sale, not how fast homes here sell; the ones that sold quickly have already left the page.

1 of the 3 homes for sale in Fenway (33%) is now priced below its original asking price, by a median 3.3%. A reduction usually means the seller is open to a conversation, and its size shows how much room they have already given.

On the resale homes for sale in Fenway, annual property tax runs about 1.39% of the asking price, a median of $22,442 a year, as reported on the MLS. The bill follows the county's assessed value and the levies of the school district and township, so two homes at the same price can differ; check the county auditor's record for a specific address.

2 listings report an HOA fee, with a median of about $124 a month as entered on the MLS. Fees are set per community and per billing period, so confirm the current amount for any specific home.

The median lot among the houses for sale in Fenway is 0.34 acres (about 14,810 square feet), from the acreage on each MLS record.

Fenway is in New Albany, Franklin County, Ohio, ZIP 43054, based on the MLS records for the homes listed there.

I'm Adam Geuy, a REALTOR with Blacktree Realty, and I work with buyers and sellers across Central Ohio. Every active listing on this page has a Book a tour button that goes straight to my calendar (Coming Soon homes open for showings on their on-market date), and a free market report if you want to know whether a home is priced right or what your own home in Fenway could bring. Call or text me at 937-239-2919.