11 homes for sale in ZIP 45654
Live from the MLS, updated Oct 19, 2026, 6:08 PM ET. Median asking $1,195,000.
By town: New Plymouth (11)
Across the region: Luxury Homes Over $1,000,000 · Homes with a Fireplace
Active $9,600,000
26711 State Route 328, New Plymouth, OH 45654
· built 2024
Keller Williams Consultants
Active $2,899,999
24801 Shurtz Road, New Plymouth, OH 45654
· built 2021
Rock House Realty LLC
Active $1,599,999 4% below original
20350 Ohio 328, New Plymouth, OH 45654
5 bd · 4 ba · 3,160 sq ft · built 2026
Rock House Realty LLC
Active $1,495,000
28170 State Route 93, New Plymouth, OH 45654
4 bd · 4 ba · 2,880 sq ft · built 2004
RE/MAX Achievers
Active $1,449,000
21844 Frantz Road, New Plymouth, OH 45654
3 bd · 3.5 ba · 2,520 sq ft · built 2027
Key Realty
Active $1,325,000 2% below original
37775 Coonville Road, New Plymouth, OH 45654
4 bd · 3 ba · 3,360 sq ft · built 1992
Howard Hanna Real Estate Svcs
Active $1,195,000 6% below original
66245 Old Shurtz Road, New Plymouth, OH 45654
6 bd · 3 ba · 1,552 sq ft · built 2020
Rock House Realty LLC
Active $975,000
24754 Shurtz Road, New Plymouth, OH 45654
2 bd · 2.5 ba · 2,025 sq ft · built 1882
Ohio Broker Direct, LLC
Active $850,000 5% below original
20328 St Rt 328, New Plymouth, OH 45654
5 bd · 3 ba · 3,600 sq ft · built 2004
EXP Realty, LLC
Active $399,900 27% below original
24215 Sheets Mccoy Road, New Plymouth, OH 45654
2 bd · 2 ba · 4,394 sq ft · built 2004
Brady Group Real Estate
Active $399,900
19431 State Route 328, New Plymouth, OH 45654
2 bd · 2 ba · 1,216 sq ft · built 1999
Rock House Realty LLC
Listings from the MLS Internet Data Exchange program, refreshed every six hours. Listing information is provided by the Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS through the Internet Data Exchange program and is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Listings held by brokerages other than Blacktree Realty are identified with the listing brokerage's name. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
ZIP 45654: what buyers ask, answered from the MLS
- Homes for sale
- 9
- Median asking price
- $1,195,000
- Asking price range
- $399,900 to $1,599,999
- Typical home
- 4 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms, 2,880 sq ft
- Median year built
- 2004
- School district
- Vinton County Local School District (most listings)
- Median days on market (active)
- 66
- Listings with a price cut
- 5 (56%)
- New construction listings
- 2
- Property tax (resale)
- about 0.73% of price, median $4,967
- Median lot size
- 12.5 acres
How many homes are for sale in ZIP 45654 right now?
9 homes are for sale in ZIP 45654 as of October 19, 2026. The count comes from the MLS's public listing feed and refreshes every six hours; a listing whose seller opted out of internet display will not appear here.
How much do homes cost in ZIP 45654?
Asking prices in ZIP 45654 run from $399,900 to $1,599,999, with a median asking price of $1,195,000, and the middle half sits between $850,000 and $1,449,000.
Is ZIP 45654 a good place to live?
That depends on what you want from a home, and the honest answer comes from the numbers rather than adjectives. In ZIP 45654 right now: the median home for sale asks $1,195,000, the typical home was built around 2004, lots run about 12.5 acres, 2 listings are new construction and most listings are in the Vinton County Local School District. Walk two or three of the listings on this page with me and you will know in an afternoon whether it fits.
What does a typical home for sale in ZIP 45654 look like?
The median listing in ZIP 45654 has 4 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms and about 2,880 finished square feet, built around 2004. Construction years on the market run from 1882 to 2027. The median asking price works out to about $481 a square foot of finished space.
What kinds of homes are for sale in ZIP 45654?
On the market in ZIP 45654 right now: 9 single-family homes, plus other property types.
What school district is ZIP 45654 in?
6 of the 11 listings in ZIP 45654 are in the Vinton County Local School District. The rest are in the Logan Hocking Local School District (5, 3.5 of 5 stars). The district comes from each listing's MLS record; attendance zones move, so confirm the assigned schools for any specific address with the district.
How long have the homes for sale in ZIP 45654 been on the market?
A median of 66 days as of October 19, 2026. That is the age of the listings still for sale, not how fast homes here sell; the ones that sold quickly have already left the page.
Are sellers in ZIP 45654 reducing their asking prices?
5 of the 9 homes for sale in ZIP 45654 (56%) are now priced below their original asking price, by a median 5.5%. A reduction usually means the seller is open to a conversation, and its size shows how much room they have already given.
Is there new construction for sale in ZIP 45654?
2 homes for sale in ZIP 45654 are new construction or built in the last two years. The on-site sales rep represents the builder, so bring your own agent to the first visit.
What are property taxes like in ZIP 45654?
On the resale homes for sale in ZIP 45654, annual property tax runs about 0.73% of the asking price, a median of $4,967 a year, as reported on the MLS. New-construction listings are left out: until the county reassesses a finished home, the MLS shows the tax on the bare lot. The bill follows the county's assessed value and the levies of the school district and township, so two homes at the same price can differ; check the county auditor's record for a specific address.
Do homes in ZIP 45654 have HOA fees?
Most of the homes for sale in ZIP 45654 report no HOA on the MLS (9 of 9).
How big are the lots in ZIP 45654?
The median lot among the houses for sale in ZIP 45654 is 12.5 acres, and 9 listings sit on an acre or more, from the acreage on each MLS record.
How do I tour a home in ZIP 45654 or find out what mine could sell for?
I'm Adam Geuy, a REALTOR with Blacktree Realty, and I work with buyers and sellers across Central Ohio. Every active listing on this page has a Book a tour button that goes straight to my calendar (Coming Soon homes open for showings on their on-market date), and a free market report if you want to know whether a home is priced right or what your own home in ZIP 45654 could bring. Call or text me at 937-239-2919.
Computed from the live MLS listings on this page, updated Oct 19, 2026, 6:08 PM ET. Answers change as the listings do.
Search the inventory another way: all homes for sale, just listed, open houses, price reductions, highest price first, lowest first.
What actually sold, by geography: school districts, ZIP codes, counties, neighborhoods, cities, homes by feature, new construction. Or have Adam run the search.