Homes for sale / Lancaster

$399,900 Active

623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130

  • 4 bed
  • 2 bath
  • 2,382 sq ft
  • 0.22 acres
  • Built 1949

About this home

Step back in time and discover the character and charm of this beautiful 1949 Cape Cod, nestled on a gorgeous street in Lancaster ! Full of timeless details and craftmanship, this home offers an abundance of built-in cabinetry, crown molding, pocket doors, generous size rooms and closets and a laundry chute ! Beautiful hardwood floors in many of the rooms, newer Luxury Vinyl and carpet in others. The first floor offers exceptional versatility, featuring two bedrooms and 1 full bath, a dedicated den with exterior private entrance, perfect for a home office ! The spacious kitchen features Corian Countertops, beautiful glass tile backsplash, white cabinetry and a gas range with exhaust hood. The living room features a decorative fireplace that adds to the homes classic character. Two additional bedrooms and full bath upstairs! Full basement offers a place to finish, a storage room with loads of shelfs and a space that could make a great workshop ! Detached 3 car garage with an additional 1 car detached garage with storage room and loft. If you appreciate the charm, craftsmanship and unique details of a well loved older home, this one is for you ! It is full of possibilities and waiting for its next owner to love ! AC and water heater 2025 ! Fridge and Stove in basement convey. Fridge and Freezer in 2nd basement room do not convey. Fridge in garage will convey. Decorative mirrors and washer & Dryer do not convey.

See it on a map

Key facts

Status
Active
Type
Single Family Residence
Days on market
2
Price per sq ft
$168
Property taxes
about $3,623/yr
Garage
4 car
County
Fairfield
MLS #
226043696
Listing brokerage
RE/MAX ONE
Listing agent
Barbara Russell
Listing brokerage contact
614-729-7555

What it would cost per month

$2,454/month estimated

Principal and interest$2,152
Property tax$302

30-year fixed at 7.11%, the Freddie Mac weekly average for November 12, 2026; tax and HOA from the MLS record. Homeowners insurance is not included, and neither is mortgage insurance, which most loans add under 20 percent down. Your rate depends on your credit and the loan.

Room by room

  • 1st floor Primary Suite
  • Lower-level Laundry
  • Den/Home Office - above grade
  • Dining Room
  • Eat-in kitchen
  • Family Room, above grade
  • Living Room
  • 2 bedroomssecond floor
  • 2 bedroomsentry level

Interior

Levels
Two
Basement
Full
Flooring
Wood, Laminate, Carpet
Appliances
Electric Water Heater, Gas Range, Refrigerator
Fireplaces
1
Fireplace
One, Decorative
Laundry
Electric Dryer Hookup

Exterior and construction

Style
Cape Cod
Foundation
Block
Porch and patio
Patio
Fencing
Fenced
Common walls
No Common Walls

Lot and parking

Lot size
0.22 acres
Lot square feet
9,583
Garage spaces
4
Parking
Garage Door Opener, Detached Garage

Systems and utilities

Cooling
Central Air
Sewer
Public Sewer
Water
Public

Taxes and HOA

Property taxes
about $3,623 a year
Tax year
2025
Parcel number
05-33075-300
HOA
None listed

Schools

District
Lancaster CSD

Sale terms

Financing accepted
VA, FHA, Conventional

Around it

Free market report

Is it priced right?

Curious how this home is listed relative to fair market value? Send a request and I'll run a report for you and send it to you. Asking prices are the seller's opinion. What the homes around it sold for is the market's.

Own a home nearby? Pick the second option and I'll value yours instead.

What do you want valued?

Or call or text me at 937-239-2919.

Shown here through the MLS IDX program by Blacktree Realty. Listing information is provided by the Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS through the Internet Data Exchange program and is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Listings held by brokerages other than Blacktree Realty are identified with the listing brokerage's name. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data last updated Nov 21, 2026, 6:12 PM.

Book a tour Is it priced right?
623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130 · 43 photos Book a tour
623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 1623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 2623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 3623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 4623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 5623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 6623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 7623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 8623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 9623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 10623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 11623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 12623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 13623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 14623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 15623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 16623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 17623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 18623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 19623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 20623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 21623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 22623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 23623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 24623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 25623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 26623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 27623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 28623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 29623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 30623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 31623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 32623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 33623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 34623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 35623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 36623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 37623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 38623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 39623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 40623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 41623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 42623 E 5th Avenue, Lancaster, OH 43130, photo 43