Homes for sale / Urbana

$375,000 Active

5164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078

  • 3 bed
  • 2 bath
  • 2,192 sq ft
  • 1.93 acres
  • Built 1900

About this home

More than just a home, this is a way of life. Rich in history, character, and charm, this historic country farmhouse once served as a tavern and inn-The Blue Bell. Here is a rare opportunity to become part of its story while embracing a simpler, more intentional way of living. Perched atop a hillside on 1.9 scenic acres just outside of Urbana, this property is full of possibilities for those dreaming of a more sustainable, self-sufficient lifestyle. Whether it's raising chickens, growing your own food, starting a hobby farm, or making room for your next 4-H project, there's space to bring those dreams to life. The property features a 52x20 pole barn, 26x20 detached garage, scenic pond, and fenced area ideal for animals. Inside, at 2,192 square feet of usable living space offers a blend of historic charm, unique character, and modern-day comforts. The farmhouse features 3 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms, including a convenient main-level bedroom and full bath. Natural light pours throughout the home, highlighting its character and creating warm, inviting spaces. The spacious living and dining areas feature walls of windows, bringing the beauty of the surrounding countryside indoors. The dining room fireplace adds to the home's timeless appeal, while sliding doors lead to a screened-in deck overlooking the peaceful landscape. Surrounded by natural light and countryside views, the enclosed wrap around porch is the perfect place to sip your morning coffee, curl up with a good book, or simply watch the seasons change. A built-in sauna adds another unexpected touch of comfort, offering a private place to relax and unwind. The Blue Bell isn't for someone looking for an ordinary home. It's for those who appreciate the stories held within old walls, the beauty of country living, and the opportunity to create a lifestyle rooted in simplicity, sustainability, and connection to the land. A home with a past, a property full of possibilities.

See it on a map

Key facts

Status
Active
Type
Single Family Residence
Days on market
1
Price per sq ft
$171
Garage
2 car
County
Champaign
MLS #
226043408
Listing brokerage
Coldwell Banker Realty
Listing agent
Erika N Fetherolf
Listing brokerage contact
937-642-3333

What it would cost per month

$2,018/month estimated

Principal and interest$2,018
Property tax (not in the listing)n/a

30-year fixed at 7.11%, the Freddie Mac weekly average for November 12, 2026; tax and HOA from the MLS record. Homeowners insurance is not included, and neither is mortgage insurance, which most loans add under 20 percent down. Your rate depends on your credit and the loan.

Room by room

  • 2 bedroomssecond floor
  • 1 bedroomentry level

Interior

Levels
Two
Basement
Full
Appliances
Gas Range, Refrigerator
Fireplace
Wood Burning Stove

Exterior and construction

Foundation
Block
Porch and patio
Porch
Fencing
Fenced
Other structures
Outbuilding
Common walls
No Common Walls

Lot and parking

Lot size
1.93 acres
Lot square feet
84,070
Garage spaces
2
Parking
Detached Garage

Systems and utilities

Heating
Forced Air, Propane
Cooling
Central Air
Sewer
Private Sewer
Water
Well

Taxes and HOA

Tax year
2025
Parcel number
G21-07-11-23-00-012-00
Township
Mad River
HOA
None listed

Schools

District
Graham LSD

Sale terms

Financing accepted
Pond on Lot, USDA Loan, VA, FHA, Conventional

Around it

Free market report

Is it priced right?

Curious how this home is listed relative to fair market value? Send a request and I'll run a report for you and send it to you. Asking prices are the seller's opinion. What the homes around it sold for is the market's.

Own a home nearby? Pick the second option and I'll value yours instead.

What do you want valued?

Or call or text me at 937-239-2919.

Shown here through the MLS IDX program by Blacktree Realty. Listing information is provided by the Columbus and Central Ohio Regional MLS through the Internet Data Exchange program and is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Listings held by brokerages other than Blacktree Realty are identified with the listing brokerage's name. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data last updated Nov 21, 2026, 6:12 PM.

Book a tour Is it priced right?
5164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078 · 54 photos Book a tour
5164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 15164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 25164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 35164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 45164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 55164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 65164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 75164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 85164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 95164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 105164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 115164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 125164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 135164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 145164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 155164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 165164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 175164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 185164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 195164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 205164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 215164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 225164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 235164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 245164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 255164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 265164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 275164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 285164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 295164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 305164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 315164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 325164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 335164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 345164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 355164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 365164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 375164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 385164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 395164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 405164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 415164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 425164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 435164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 445164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 455164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 465164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 475164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 485164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 495164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 505164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 515164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 525164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 535164 W US Highway 36, Urbana, OH 43078, photo 54