Central Ohio · Historic Homes Built Before 1940 · Mount Sterling

Historic Homes Built Before 1940 in Mount Sterling

25 pre-1940 homes closed in Mount Sterling in 2026 through November 9, 2026, 40.3% of every sale in town, at a median of $228,000. The comparison that matters is Mount Sterling itself, not the region, so that is what sits beside every number here.

25closings, 2026 YTD
$228,000median sale price
17median days on market
5on the market now

Historic Homes Built Before 1940 versus all of Mount Sterling

MeasureHistoric Homes Built Before 1940All Mount Sterling closings
Median sale price$228,000$290,000
Median price per square foot$143$181
Median days on market1719
Median year built1930
Closed under $300,00076%
Closed at $500,000 or more8%
Active listings today5median asking $199,900

These homes cleared 21% under the Mount Sterling median. That gap is size, age and lot as much as the feature. Send me the address and I will pull the comparables that actually apply.

Where this sits

ZIP codes with these sales: 43143. School districts serving Mount Sterling: Madison Plains Local School District, Westfall Local School District. All pre-1940 homes across Central Ohio: Historic Homes Built Before 1940.

Looking for pre-1940 homes in Mount Sterling?

Tell me the budget and I will run the search on the MLS field, not the adjective, and check the parcel record on anything you want to see. Call or text 937-239-2919, or tell me what you are looking for.

Start the search

Questions people ask

How much do pre-1940 homes cost in Mount Sterling?

A median of $228,000 across 25 closings between January 1 and November 9, 2026, against $290,000 for all Mount Sterling closings. 76% closed under $300,000 and 8% at $500,000 or more.

How fast do pre-1940 homes sell in Mount Sterling?

Median 17 days from list to contract, against 19 for the town as a whole. 5 are on the market right now at a median asking price of $199,900.

How is "pre-1940 homes" defined here?

By the MLS record: year built 1940 or earlier. Not by a listing description, so the count is reproducible.

Data: MLS closings and active listings compiled by Adam Geuy, Blacktree Realty, through November 9, 2026. Aggregates only.