Central Ohio · Neighborhoods · Pickerington

Sheffield

8 homes closed in Sheffield between January 1, 2025 and November 9, 2026, from $385,000 to $464,900, median $435,000. Small sample, so read the range before the median. Two years of sales are shown because only 4 have closed here in 2026. The neighborhood is measured against Pickerington itself, because that is the choice a buyer here is actually making.

8closings, 2025 to 2026
$435,000median sale price
19median days on market
0on the market now

Sheffield versus all of Pickerington

MeasureSheffieldAll Pickerington closings
Median sale price, 2025 to 2026$435,000$430,000
Range of 2025 to 2026 sales$385,000 to $464,900
By year4 closed in 2025 (median $434,000); 4 in 2026 (median $435,000)
Median price per square foot$139$185
Median days on market1910
Median year built2004
Closed under $300,0000%
Closed at $500,000 or more0%
Active listings at the export date0median asking not listed

Sheffield cleared 1% above the Pickerington median. The subdivision name is typed by the listing agent, so a few homes are always filed under a variant; these are the ones the MLS agrees on.

Buying or selling in Sheffield?

The comparables that matter are the ones on these streets, and I have every one of them. Call or text 937-239-2919, tell me what you are looking for, or ask what your house would bring.

What would mine sell for?

Questions people ask about Sheffield

What do homes in Sheffield sell for?

8 closed between January 1, 2025 and November 9, 2026, from $385,000 to $464,900, median $435,000. Pickerington as a whole ran $430,000 over the same dates.

How fast do homes in Sheffield sell?

Median 19 days from list to contract, against 10 for Pickerington. 0 listed right now at a median asking price of not listed.

What school district is Sheffield in?

Closings in Pickerington this year fell mostly in Pickerington Local School District, Canal Winchester Local School District, Liberty Union Thurst. The parcel record decides for a specific address, and attendance zones inside a district move.

What is the price per square foot in Sheffield?

Homes that closed in Sheffield between January 1, 2025 and November 9, 2026 sold for a median $139 per finished square foot, against $185 for Pickerington over the same dates. Price per foot rewards small homes and punishes big ones, so use it to compare Sheffield with the next neighborhood, not to price one house.

How old are the homes in Sheffield?

The homes that sold in Sheffield between January 1, 2025 and November 9, 2026 were built in a median year of 2004. The roof, furnace and windows on a specific house are on its inspection report, not here.

What kinds of homes are in Sheffield?

Of the 8 homes that sold in Sheffield between January 1, 2025 and November 9, 2026, 8 were single-family homes, as the MLS records the property type.

How big are the lots in Sheffield?

The median lot among the homes that sold in Sheffield between January 1, 2025 and November 9, 2026 was 0.24 acres, about 10,454 square feet, as listing agents entered it. The county auditor's parcel record has the exact dimensions for a specific address.

Is Sheffield in a flood zone?

None of the 8 homes that sold since January 2025 or are listed now in Sheffield sit inside FEMA's Special Flood Hazard Area, the 1-percent-annual-chance floodplain where a federally backed mortgage requires flood insurance, on the current flood map. The flood map is drawn by the parcel, so check the specific address on FEMA's Map Service Center before you write an offer. Mapped November 22, 2026.

Source: FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer

How far is Sheffield from downtown and the hospitals?

Measured in a straight line from the center of the homes that sold there, Sheffield is about 13 miles from downtown Columbus, about 15 miles from OSU Wexner Medical Center, about 11 miles from Nationwide Children's Hospital and about 10 miles from John Glenn Columbus International Airport. Those are map distances, not drive times; traffic on the specific route decides the commute, and I will drive it with you at the hour you would.

Where is Sheffield located?

Sheffield is in Pickerington, Fairfield County, Ohio, ZIP code 43147, with this year's closings falling in the Pickerington Local School District and Canal Winchester Local School District and Liberty Union Thurst. The subdivision name is the one the MLS records on each listing; the county parcel record settles any address.

How many people live in Sheffield?

The Census reports on towns and ZIP codes, not on Sheffield itself. Pickerington, the town around Sheffield, had 24,477 residents in 8,420 households, median age 36, in the 2020-2024 American Community Survey. It counts 8,882 housing units, 69% of them single-family detached houses.

Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020-2024 5-year estimates (via Census Reporter)

What is the median household income in Sheffield?

The Census reports on towns and ZIP codes, not on Sheffield itself. The median household in Pickerington, the town around Sheffield earned $111,833 a year (2020-2024 ACS, in that period's dollars). 77% of occupied homes are owner-occupied; the median gross rent is $1,605 a month.

Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020-2024 5-year estimates (via Census Reporter)

What are homes in Sheffield worth, according to the Census?

The Census reports on towns and ZIP codes, not on Sheffield itself. Owners in Pickerington, the town around Sheffield put the median value of their homes at $339,600 in the 2020-2024 survey. That is an owner's estimate averaged over five years, not a sale price; the MLS median that actually closed this year is $435,000. The median home there was built in 2003.

Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020-2024 5-year estimates (via Census Reporter)

How long is the commute from Sheffield?

The Census reports on towns and ZIP codes, not on Sheffield itself. 57% of workers living in Pickerington, the town around Sheffield got to work in under 30 minutes (2020-2024 ACS). That is the residents' own reported travel time, not a drive-time estimate for any address.

Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020-2024 5-year estimates (via Census Reporter)

Data: MLS closings and active listings compiled by Adam Geuy, Blacktree Realty, through November 9, 2026. Aggregates only; no individual sale is shown.