What Home Inspection Problems Are Deal Breakers in Columbus?
Six things on a home inspection report decide whether a deal keeps going: the roof, the windows, the foundation, the mechanicals, the appliances and the siding. Water is the thread through most of them. The rest of the report is pretty small and easy to fix. Replacing the big ones is where the money is. The 2025 Cost vs. Value report puts an asphalt roof replacement at $29,253 and vinyl siding at $19,139 in the East North Central region, which includes Ohio. InterNACHI's life expectancy chart gives a gas furnace 15 to 25 years and a water heater 6 to 12. In Franklin County about half of the housing was built before 1980, so most reports here run long. The length of the report tells you almost nothing. What's on it is what matters.
I'm Adam Geuy, a Realtor with Blacktree Realty in Columbus. My dad, my grandpa, my uncle and my great-grandpa were builders, and I did it until I was twenty. I'm not a home inspector and I'm not crawling around in your attic, but I can look at a foundation and tell you if it's copacetic or not. When I read an inspection report with a buyer, I look at it in two piles, and that's how this post is laid out.
What shows up on almost every inspection report but isn't a big deal?
A long report with dozens of items scares people. Most of those items are things I see on report after report, on houses at every price, and most of them are an afternoon and a trip to the hardware store.
- Outlets without GFCI protection in kitchens, baths, garages and outside. Often one GFCI outlet at the start of the circuit covers the rest.
- Missing or loose handrails on basement and deck stairs.
- Downspouts that dump right at the foundation. An extension or a splash block fixes it. Cheap, and important, because this is where a lot of wet basements start.
- Caulk and weatherstripping at tubs, windows and exterior doors.
- Smoke and carbon monoxide detectors missing or past their date.
- A dripping faucet, a running toilet, a slow drain.
- Furnace filter overdue, dryer vent full of lint.
- Grading that slopes toward the house in one spot, or mulch piled against the siding.
- Hairline cracks in the driveway, the garage floor and the basement slab.
None of these are a reason to walk. Some are a reason to ask, and most are a reason to make a list for your first weekend in the house. Ohio's own disclosure form draws the same line. Its structural question asks sellers about material cracks and settling "other than visible minor cracks or blemishes."
Which inspection items matter?
The big six are the items that are expensive to replace, hard to see, or both. This table is how I sort them. The life expectancy numbers come from InterNACHI, the home inspectors' association, which calls them guidelines and not guarantees.
| Item | Typical life (InterNACHI) | What I look at | When it matters |
|---|---|---|---|
| Roof, asphalt shingles | 20 years (3-tab), 30 (architectural) | Curling, missing granules, stains on the attic deck | Near end of life, active leaks, two layers |
| Windows | Vinyl 20 to 40 years; double-pane seal 8 to 20 | Fogged glass, soft sills, stains below the window | Water getting into the wall |
| Foundation | 100+ years for poured concrete or block | Crack direction, width, bowing, water | Horizontal cracks, bowing, active movement |
| Furnace | 15 to 25 years (gas, forced air) | Data plate date, rust at the base, service tags | Past the range, or cracked heat exchanger noted |
| Central air conditioner | 7 to 15 years | Data plate date on the outdoor unit | Past the range in a house you plan to keep |
| Water heater | 6 to 12 years (conventional tank) | Data plate date, rust, water in the pan | Leaking, or past the range |
| Electrical panel | 60 years for the service panel | Brand, double taps, scorch marks, panel age | Any sign of heat, or a panel the inspector flags by name |
| Siding | Vinyl 60 years; fiber cement 100+ | Cracked or loose pieces, rot at the bottom edge | Rot behind it, water at the sill plate |
| Appliances | Dishwasher 9 years; refrigerator 9 to 13 | Age and whether they run | Rarely a deal breaker; a negotiating line |
Appliances are on the list because they add up when a whole kitchen is at the end of its range at once. They're the easiest of the six to price and the least likely to change my mind about a house.
Which foundation cracks are deal breakers?
Direction tells you most of the story.
Hairline vertical cracks, or diagonal ones that stay the same width, in a poured concrete wall are almost always shrinkage. InterNACHI's structural training for inspectors says those cracks "may allow water entry" but are not a structural defect. Seal it if it leaks, and move on.
Stair-step cracks along the mortar joints of a block wall are the ones people panic about, and most of the time they shouldn't. InterNACHI says drying shrinkage in block walls often makes a diagonal pattern that looks like settlement, usually forms in the building's first year and "is rarely serious." If the crack is old, hairline and the blocks on each side still line up, it's a seal-and-watch item. A stair-step crack that's wide at one end and hairline at the other, sits near a corner, or comes with sticking doors and sloping floors is settlement, and that's an engineer.
A horizontal crack is the one I stop on. InterNACHI's training says horizontal cracks are not caused by settlement. They're caused by pressure on the outside of the wall below the ground, most often from how the dirt was backfilled, sometimes from expansive soil or frost. The wall is holding up the house and the soil is pushing it in. Left alone, the wall can bow and even collapse. That doesn't always mean walk. It means a structural engineer looks at it before your inspection window closes, and the repair gets priced before you negotiate.
For the full basement walk, sump pump to beams, here is my basement inspection checklist for Columbus buyers.
How old is too old for the furnace, the air conditioner and the water heater?
Older than the ranges in the table is old, and I'd plan for it. A 22-year-old furnace that runs fine still runs fine. You just shouldn't be surprised when it goes, and you shouldn't pay for the house like it's new.
Ohio's licensing rules for home inspectors say an inspector is not required to give an opinion on the remaining life of a system, or on what it costs to fix. Some will tell you anyway. Most will note the age if they can read it and move on. So find the data plate on each unit and read the manufacture date yourself, or have me do it on the walkthrough before you write the offer. That date is the most useful number on the whole mechanical page.
What does it cost to fix the big items?
The best regional numbers are in the Cost vs. Value report from the Journal of Light Construction and Zonda. These are 2025 averages for the East North Central region, on the report's own specified project, not a quote for your house.
| Project | Job cost, East North Central | National job cost |
|---|---|---|
| Asphalt shingle roof replacement | $29,253 | $31,871 |
| Vinyl window replacement | $22,054 | $22,073 |
| Fiber-cement siding replacement | $23,515 | $21,485 |
| Vinyl siding replacement | $19,139 | $17,950 |
If a house has a 25-year-old roof, original windows and old siding, that's a five-figure problem stacked three times. That's the point of sorting the report. Thirty small items might add up to a weekend. One of these can be the whole down payment. For the roof in more detail, here is how old is too old for a roof in Columbus.
What should you ask the seller to fix after the inspection?
Ask for what's expensive, structural, unsafe or letting water in. Let the rest go. A buyer who sends a 40-line repair request usually gets a seller who digs in on all 40, including the three that mattered.
On a big item I'd usually rather have a credit or a price reduction than a seller-managed repair. The seller is leaving. Their incentive is the cheapest fix that clears the inspection, and you're the one living with it. With a credit you pick the contractor and you control the work. Some loans limit how much a seller can credit, so that conversation includes your lender.
If you're tempted to skip the inspection entirely to win a house, read should you waive the home inspection in Columbus first. And it helps to know what's outside an inspector's scope before the report shows up, so here is what a home inspection actually covers in Ohio.
Is radon a deal breaker in Columbus?
Rarely. It's common on reports and it's fixable. The EPA recommends fixing a home that tests at 4 picocuries per liter or higher and says to consider it between 2 and 4. The fix is a mitigation system, a known item you can get bid. In Ohio, anyone other than the owner who tests for radon has to hold a radon tester license from the state, so if your inspector offers a radon test, ask to see it.
When should you walk away from a house after the inspection?
Not over the small pile. And usually not over one item from the big pile, because a known item can be priced. I'd walk, or seriously think about it, in four cases.
- A horizontal crack comes with a bowing wall and the engineer's fix is more than the deal can carry.
- There's water and nobody can tell you where it's coming from. Fresh paint on one basement wall, a new dehumidifier running hard and a seller who checked "no" on the water intrusion question is a combination I don't like.
- Three or four of the big six are at the end of their life and the house is priced like they were replaced.
- The seller won't negotiate on a structural or water item and the inspection window is about to close.
The Ohio disclosure form asks sellers about past and current water leakage and structural problems, but only what they know. It isn't a warranty and it isn't a substitute for an inspection. It says so in capital letters at the top.
If you're buying in Columbus and want somebody next to you who reads the report this way, call or text me at 937-239-2919 or book a time at calendly.com/adam-geuy. I'll walk the house with you before you write, and we'll go through the report together when it lands. If Westerville is on your list, start with what's for sale there now.
Life expectancy figures are from InterNACHI's Standard Estimated Life Expectancy Chart for Homes. Crack descriptions are from InterNACHI's Structural Issues for Home Inspectors study guide and its Inspecting Foundation Walls and Piers manual. Cost figures are from the Cost vs. Value Report 2025, East North Central region. Housing age is from the U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2024 1-year estimates, table B25034. Inspector scope is from Ohio Administrative Code 1301:17-1-17. Radon guidance is from the U.S. EPA and Ohio Revised Code 3723.02.
Columbus by the numbers
7,054 homes closed in Columbus in 2026 through November 9, 2026, median $285,000, middle half $203,000 to $405,000, a median 11 days on market. 1865 active today, 2.9 months of supply. Full read: the Columbus housing market page.
- ZIP codes: 43207 (556 sales, median $225,000), 43230 (545 sales, median $355,000), 43228 (505 sales, median $282,500), 43204 (431 sales, median $215,000), 43235 (403 sales, median $425,000), 43221 (392 sales, median $500,000)
- School districts: Columbus City School District (2.5 of 5 on the state report card), South-Western City School District (3.5 of 5 on the state report card), Hilliard City School District (4.5 of 5 on the state report card), Westerville City School District (3.5 of 5 on the state report card)
- Neighborhoods with enough sales to measure: Clintonville (165), Merion Village (69), German Village (64), Westgate (44), South Of Lane (43), Worthington Hills (42), Blacklick Estates (41), Southern Orchards (39)
- By feature: homes with a pool in Columbus (266), condos and flats in Columbus (1269), homes on an acre or more in Columbus (61), homes with a 3-car garage in Columbus (174), historic homes built before 1940 in Columbus (1586), new construction in Columbus (238)
MLS record, aggregates only, refreshed monthly. A town median describes the town; the comparables for one house are a different pull.
Common questions
What are the biggest deal breakers on a home inspection?
The roof, windows, foundation, mechanicals (furnace, air conditioner, water heater and electrical panel), appliances and siding, plus any sign of water getting into the house. A horizontal crack in a basement wall, especially with the wall bowing in, is the foundation finding that calls for a structural engineer before you go further.
Are stair-step cracks in a basement wall bad?
Usually not, if they are hairline, old and the blocks on both sides still line up. InterNACHI's inspector training says drying-shrinkage cracks in block walls are rarely serious. A stair-step crack that tapers wide at one end, sits near a corner with sticking doors or sloping floors, or has blocks pushed out of line points to settlement and deserves an engineer.
How long do a furnace, air conditioner and water heater last?
InterNACHI's life expectancy chart puts a gas forced-air furnace at 15 to 25 years, a central air conditioner at 7 to 15 years and a conventional water heater at 6 to 12 years. Ohio's home inspection rules do not require an inspector to estimate remaining life, so read the data plates on each unit for the manufacture date.
What should you ask the seller to fix after a home inspection?
Ask for the items that are expensive, structural, a safety issue or letting water in, and let the cosmetic and maintenance items go. A credit at closing is often cleaner than a seller-managed repair on a big item, because you pick the contractor and control the quality.
Is radon a deal breaker in Columbus?
Rarely. The EPA recommends fixing a home that tests at 4 picocuries per liter or higher, and a mitigation system is a known, fixable item. In Ohio, anyone testing for radon other than the owner must hold a state radon tester license.