What new construction actually sold for in Columbus
Every MLS closing marked new construction across Central Ohio since January 2025, through November 9, 2026, against every resale in the same towns. Builder brochures show asking prices. This shows what closed.
New construction vs resale across Central Ohio
| New construction | Resale | |
|---|---|---|
| Closings | 5,057 | 49,402 |
| Median sold price | $480,000 | $325,000 |
| Per sq ft | $214 | $190 |
| Median lot | 0.19 acre | 0.2 acre |
| Median year built | 2025 | 1979 |
| Sold vs original list | 100% | 98.6% |
MLS closings marked new construction, and every other closing for the resale column, January 2025 through November 9, 2026. Builders often enter a home in the MLS once it is already under contract, which is why days on market is left out and the sold-to-list figure runs high.
New vs resale, town by town
Towns with at least 5 new-construction closings, most sales first. "Premium" is new construction's price per square foot against resale in the same town.
| Town | New closings | New median | New $/sq ft | Resale median | Resale $/sq ft | Premium |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Plain City | 626 | $553,214 | $228 | $565,000 | $222 | +3% |
| Columbus | 413 | $357,016 | $205 | $272,000 | $191 | +7% |
| Delaware | 411 | $529,900 | $219 | $397,700 | $196 | +12% |
| Grove City | 353 | $505,490 | $207 | $337,500 | $191 | +8% |
| Powell | 279 | $515,710 | $224 | $550,000 | $213 | +5% |
| Pickerington | 214 | $551,246 | $210 | $414,000 | $178 | +18% |
| Hilliard | 191 | $596,000 | $228 | $378,750 | $210 | +9% |
| Canal Winchester | 164 | $428,224 | $190 | $325,000 | $180 | +6% |
| Marysville | 164 | $474,978 | $199 | $375,000 | $184 | +8% |
| Sunbury | 154 | $574,945 | $210 | $499,900 | $216 | -3% |
| Lewis Center | 149 | $610,000 | $265 | $510,000 | $202 | +31% |
| Galloway | 137 | $386,000 | $182 | $315,000 | $194 | -6% |
| South Bloomfield | 135 | $385,748 | $166 | $337,000 | $164 | +1% |
| Newark | 116 | $330,402 | $208 | $250,000 | $171 | +22% |
| Galena | 109 | $502,610 | $217 | $672,500 | $209 | +4% |
| Dublin | 103 | $754,802 | $264 | $516,200 | $215 | +23% |
| Commercial Point | 95 | $459,441 | $212 | $415,000 | $169 | +25% |
| Westerville | 94 | $538,770 | $253 | $427,450 | $206 | +23% |
| Reynoldsburg | 94 | $433,170 | $197 | $292,200 | $178 | +11% |
| Pataskala | 92 | $510,456 | $210 | $375,000 | $189 | +11% |
| Circleville | 85 | $389,900 | $176 | $280,000 | $174 | +1% |
| Bellefontaine | 84 | $361,357 | $173 | $245,000 | $168 | +3% |
| Ashville | 83 | $386,550 | $188 | $345,000 | $187 | +1% |
| Howard | 62 | $386,500 | $199 | $325,000 | $182 | +9% |
| London | 61 | $379,071 | $173 | $293,000 | $185 | -6% |
| New Albany | 54 | $489,900 | $230 | $575,000 | $226 | +2% |
| Lithopolis | 51 | $419,785 | $187 | $376,000 | $171 | +9% |
| Etna | 47 | $307,000 | $171 | $375,000 | $179 | -4% |
| Washington Court House | 34 | $341,200 | $169 | $220,000 | $156 | +8% |
| Blacklick | 27 | $839,500 | $242 | $350,000 | $186 | +30% |
| Zanesville | 25 | $348,999 | $189 | $247,500 | $156 | +21% |
| Logan | 25 | $429,000 | $260 | $285,700 | $176 | +48% |
| Lockbourne | 21 | $434,900 | $182 | $305,900 | $182 | 0% |
| Thornville | 21 | $355,000 | $212 | $350,000 | $219 | -3% |
| Mount Vernon | 19 | $415,000 | $260 | $250,000 | $164 | +59% |
| Mount Gilead | 19 | $325,000 | $160 | $282,450 | $176 | -9% |
| Heath | 17 | $480,000 | $176 | $285,050 | $193 | -9% |
| Hebron | 16 | $401,760 | $227 | $375,000 | $200 | +14% |
| Johnstown | 14 | $477,500 | $316 | $426,750 | $221 | +43% |
| Marion | 12 | $362,450 | $197 | $183,500 | $134 | +47% |
| Mansfield | 12 | $289,900 | $184 | $224,000 | $140 | +31% |
| Centerburg | 8 | $462,900 | $241 | $409,000 | $216 | +12% |
| Lancaster | 8 | $433,950 | $226 | $262,250 | $174 | +30% |
| South Charleston | 7 | $275,180 | $150 | $249,900 | $162 | -7% |
| Bremen | 7 | $362,900 | $242 | $255,000 | $165 | +47% |
| Cardington | 7 | $446,000 | $197 | $294,250 | $179 | +10% |
| Jeffersonville | 7 | $381,395 | $163 | $211,000 | $140 | +16% |
| New Straitsville | 6 | $225,200 | $166 | $165,000 | $103 | +61% |
| Buckeye Lake | 6 | $502,450 | $254 | $249,000 | $209 | +22% |
| Obetz | 6 | $340,450 | $232 | $242,500 | $172 | +35% |
| Utica | 6 | $406,450 | $221 | $235,000 | $171 | +29% |
| Chillicothe | 5 | $297,400 | $224 | $240,000 | $146 | +53% |
| Millersport | 5 | $365,000 | $227 | $450,000 | $261 | -13% |
| Marengo | 5 | $575,000 | $273 | $365,000 | $199 | +37% |
| Granville | 5 | $479,900 | $244 | $514,900 | $213 | +15% |
| Laurelville | 5 | $389,000 | $207 | $397,450 | $227 | -9% |
By builder
Attributed only in communities with a single builder, so a shared community counts for no one.
| Builder | Closings | Median sold | $/sq ft | Median lot |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fischer Homes | 786 | $532,308 | $207 | 0.2 ac |
| M/I Homes | 734 | $512,688 | $225 | 0.17 ac |
| D.R. Horton | 631 | $406,240 | $205 | 0.19 ac |
| Pulte | 578 | $524,940 | $206 | 0.18 ac |
| Epcon | 60 | $627,412 | $278 | 0.17 ac |
| Maronda | 54 | $312,088 | $170 | 0.19 ac |
| Rockford Homes | 26 | $580,414 | $218 | 0.22 ac |
| Arbor Homes | 23 | $419,000 | $186 | 0.17 ac |
| 3 Pillar | 23 | $866,287 | $271 | 0.18 ac |
| K. Hovnanian | 18 | $324,995 | $158 | 0.26 ac |
| Romanelli | 14 | $1,001,500 | $317 | 0.17 ac |
| Homewood | 10 | $542,400 | $202 | 0.25 ac |
| Bob Webb | 7 | $1,020,000 | $318 | 0.22 ac |
| Schottenstein | 6 | $401,000 | $207 | 0.13 ac |
Head to head: Fischer Homes vs M/I Homes · Fischer Homes vs D.R. Horton · Fischer Homes vs Pulte · Fischer Homes vs Epcon · Fischer Homes vs Maronda · M/I Homes vs D.R. Horton · M/I Homes vs Pulte · M/I Homes vs Epcon. By price: Under $350K · $350K to $500K · $500K to $750K · $750K and up.
How this is built
Source: closed sales in the MLS, through the Internet Data Exchange feed, that the listing agent marked as new construction, since January 2025. Resale is every other closed residential sale in the same towns. Figures are medians. A town or builder needs at least 5 closings to appear. Sales under $75,000 (new) and $20,000 (resale) are left out as data-entry errors. Days on market is not shown: builders often enter a home once it is already under contract. Rebuilt every week.
Cite this report: Adam Geuy, Blacktree Realty, "Columbus New Construction Market Report," betterhomestrategy.com/new-construction/market-report/, data through November 9, 2026.
Questions people ask
How much does new construction cost in Columbus?
New construction across Central Ohio closed at a median $480,000, about $214 per square foot, on 5,057 MLS closings since January 2025, through November 9, 2026. Resale homes closed at a median $325,000, about $190 per square foot.
Is new construction more expensive than resale in Columbus?
Per square foot, new construction ran 13 percent above resale across Central Ohio. It is not the same everywhere: in 10 of 56 towns with enough sales to compare, new homes closed below resale per square foot, including Sunbury, Galloway, London, Etna.
Which builders sell the most new homes in Columbus?
By MLS closings since January 2025: Fischer Homes (786), M/I Homes (734), D.R. Horton (631), Pulte (578), Epcon (60). Counted only in communities with a single builder, so shared communities are left out.
Want the numbers for a specific community or builder? Book a 15 minute call