New Construction ยท Compare builders

M/I Homes vs D.R. Horton

Two of the busiest builders in Central Ohio, side by side on what their homes actually closed at in the MLS since January 2025, not what the brochure says. M/I Homes closed 734 homes and D.R. Horton closed 631.

M/I Homes and D.R. Horton by the numbers

M/I HomesD.R. Horton
Homes sold since January 2025734631
Median sold price$512,688$406,240
Sold price per sq ft$225$205
Sold price range$320,600 to $960,533$290,962 to $660,503
Median lot0.17 acre0.19 acre
Sold vs original list96.3%100%
Communities on this site2637
Listed now from$318,410$299,900

Per square foot, D.R. Horton closed 9 percent below M/I Homes. MLS closings marked new construction and attributed by community, only where a community has a single builder. Builders often enter a home once it is already under contract, so the sold-to-list figure runs high for both.

Where M/I Homes builds

Most closings: Darby Station (118), Clarkshaw Crossing (92), Berlin Farm (67), Liberty Grand (54).

Where D.R. Horton builds

Most closings: Madison Meadows (123), Villas at Renner Park (54), Longview Highlands (51), Walnut Mill (51).

Towns where you can compare them head to head

Questions people ask

Is M/I Homes or D.R. Horton cheaper in Central Ohio?

On the median sale, D.R. Horton ($406,240) against M/I Homes ($512,688), from MLS closings since January 2025. Per square foot, D.R. Horton closed at $205 and M/I Homes at $225, which is the fairer comparison because the two sell different sizes. The base price on either one is a starting line; lot premium, structural options and the design studio sit on top.

Who builds on bigger lots, M/I Homes or D.R. Horton?

The median D.R. Horton home that closed sat on 0.19 acre, against 0.17 acre for M/I Homes. Lot size moves a lot between communities, so check the plat for the specific lot.

Where do M/I Homes and D.R. Horton both build?

Both have communities in Delaware, Pickerington, Plain City. That is where the comparison is cleanest: same town, two builders.

Do I need an agent to compare M/I Homes and D.R. Horton?

It costs nothing to have one, because both builders budget a cooperating commission. Register your agent on the first visit to each sales office, or that builder will generally treat you as their own customer.

Weighing these two? Book a 15 minute call and I'll walk you through the communities and the numbers before you visit either sales office.

More comparisons: Fischer Homes vs M/I Homes, Fischer Homes vs D.R. Horton, M/I Homes vs Pulte, M/I Homes vs Epcon, M/I Homes vs Maronda, D.R. Horton vs Pulte, D.R. Horton vs Epcon, D.R. Horton vs Maronda.